U.S. states saw their tax revenue drop by about $31 billion, or 6 percent, from March through August, compared to the same period a year earlier, as the pandemic triggered economic shutdowns across the country, according to data from 44 states compiled by the Urban Institute.
The scale of the drop appears smaller than expected, relative to the depth of the economic contraction, and comes after several states have reported that their revenue didn’t decline as much as anticipated despite business shutdowns and increased unemployment. In August, when much of the country was reopening, state revenue climbed about 1.1 percent from a year earlier, the Urban Institute found.
Michael Schor is a partner in Deloitte & Touche LLP's audit and assurance practice, where he focuses on advising our domestic and international clients on matters of internal controls, including information technology, regulatory matters, risk management issues, and control and compliance management processes. He leads Deloitte's internal audit practice, with more than 20 years of experience advising Deloitte's largest clients on the various elements of the internal audit lifecycle, including risk assessments, audit planning and execution, and reporting to audit committees and key executive stakeholders.
Ryan Hittner is an audit and assurance principal at Deloitte with more than 15 years of management consulting experience, specializing in strategic advisory to global financial institutions focusing on banking and capital markets. He co-leads Deloitte's artificial intelligence and algorithmic practice which is dedicated to advising clients in developing and deploying responsible AI including risk frameworks, governance, and controls related to artificial intelligence and advanced algorithms. He also serves as deputy leader of Deloitte's valuation and analytics practice where he leads Deloitte's Omnia DNAV Derivatives technologies, which incorporate automation, machine learning, and large datasets.
Simon Williams is vice president of the accountant segment at Intuit.
The tax figures come as Republicans in Washington balk at extending aid to states and cities to help cover budget deficits that are expected to continue as the coronavirus weighs on the economy. Experts say that states’ financial outlooks could worsen as the effects of the stimulus bill fade and high unemployment reduces tax bills next year.
The August increase should be viewed with caution since income-tax deadlines were pushed back to July, which could have resulted in some revenue being processed later, according to Lucy Dadayan, senior research associate with the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center at the Urban Institute. Personal income-tax collections, which rose 3.8 percent in August, were in some cases supported by backlogged unemployment insurance benefits subject to withholding tax, Dadayan said.
Between March and August, tax revenues fell 6.4 percent year over year, with 36 states reporting declines over that period, the report said. Between March and August, eight states, including Washington and Georgia, reported growth in tax revenue.
“Due to the shifting in timing of tax receipts this past year, it is crucial to view August year-over-year revenue gains and fiscal year to date data with caution,” Dadayan said in the report.